If you run a Shopify store, you’ve probably heard or read somewhere that installing too many apps can slow down your store speed. In fact - it’s a question we deal with a lot with our own customers.

It’s a pervasive belief. Developers, agencies, and even Shopify forums often blame third-party apps for sluggish load times, warning merchants to cut back or risk hurting SEO and sales. 

The truth is – poorly built apps can harm performance, but the idea that all apps dramatically slow down your store is a myth.

Well-optimized apps (like those having the Built for Shopify badge) have a negligible impact on speed. 

We installed and compared the 3 most popular GDPR/CCPA cookie banner apps on a clean Shopify store, measured their impact using trusted tools, and dug into the numbers.

Why Store Speed Matters For Shopify Merchants

Although technical in nature, store speed is directly tied to your revenue, SEO, and customer experience. 

Studies have shown that a 1-second delay in page load can reduce conversions by 7% and increase bounce rates significantly. 

Also, for years now Google has used speed signals (especially Core Web Vitals) as a ranking factor in the search results. 

This means when two pages are similar in relevance and content, Google favors the faster-loading one (especially for mobile users). 

So - if your competitor's store loads faster, they might outrank you even if you are selling the same thing.

Online shoppers also expect instant-load websites. If your store feels slow or unstable, visitors are more likely to abandon it even before seeing your products. 

This is especially true if you are selling to customers located in countries with fast internet connection (such as UAE, Iceland, France, Spain).

Key Store Speed Metrics

Whether you're tracking performance inside PageSpeed Insights or reading a Shopify theme audit, you'll often see terms like LCP, TBT, and FCP. 

They are standardized metrics used across the web to evaluate how fast (and smooth) a site loads to your visitors.

For Shopify merchants, understanding these metrics can help you troubleshoot problems, choose better apps, improve customer experience and SEO.

Here is a short description of each: 

• LCP (Largest Contentful Paint): How fast the main content loads (e.g., hero image or product title).
  Goal: Under 2.5 seconds.
• TBT (Total Blocking Time): How long the page feels "frozen" during loading.
  Goal: Under 200ms.
• FCP (First Contentful Paint): When any visible element (text, image, logo, etc.) appears. Goal: Under 1.8 seconds.

Speed Matters But So Does Compliance

But there’s another, equally important reality for Shopify merchants today: you can’t ignore privacy laws.

If your store receives traffic from Europe, California (or these 12+ states), Australia or other regions with strict data laws, you’re expected to:

• Show a cookie consent banner.
• Respect opt-in / opt-out preferences.
• Delay certain tracking scripts until user permission is granted.

For many merchants selling in a regulated customer privacy market - using a cookie consent app is a legal necessity.

So we asked the big question:

Can you stay compliant and keep your store fast?

‍

To find out, we set up a test store and ran real performance benchmarks on three popular cookie banner apps.

Test Setup: How We Measured It

To get a real-world sense of how cookie banner apps affect performance, we created a controlled environment using a Shopify demo store. 

Here’s exactly how we set it up:

Store Configuration

• Theme: Dawn (Shopify’s default theme - lightweight and widely used)
• Products: 10 dummy products (with images, descriptions, prices)
• No other custom apps or scripts installed - to isolate performance impact

Cookie Banner Apps Tested

We chose three widely-used, feature-rich apps that merchants rely on for GDPR and CCPA compliance:

• Consentmo GDPR Compliance
• Pandectes GDPR Compliance
• Avada GDPR Cookies Consent

Each app was installed one at a time, with standard banner settings enabled (basic display, geolocation where available, and default behavior). No heavy customizations or visual tweaks were made.

Testing Tools Used

We used two of the most respected tools for performance analysis:

• Google PageSpeed Insights

Measures Core Web Vitals like LCP and overall performance score.

• WebPageTest.org

Gives a detailed look at TTFB, load time, requests, and JavaScript execution.

Each setup was tested multiple times, and results were averaged to account for minor fluctuations.

Up next, we’ll show you exactly what we found — and which app came out on top.

The Real Results: Do Cookie Apps Slow You Down?

With the tests complete, we pulled together the data to see how each app performed and if the myth about "apps slowing down your store" holds up.

We focused on six key performance metrics:

• LCP (Largest Contentful Paint): how long until the main content appears.
• TTFB (Time to First Byte): server responsiveness.
• Total Load Time: how long the full page takes to load.
• Performance Score (PageSpeed Insights): an overall measure of speed.
• # of Network Requests: how many assets the browser loads.
• JavaScript Execution Time: client-side workload (estimated).

Here’s what we found:

In other words:

• Without any cookie banner, the store loaded in 2.19 seconds (fast!).
• With Consentmo, it took 2.49 seconds - just 0.3s slower (barely noticeable).
• Other apps added 0.6–0.9s extra load time - that’s 2–3x slower than Consentmo.

The baseline (no banner) was the fastest option, but it is a non-compliant setup for stores selling to customers in regulated regions (like Europe, many US States, Australia).

You need a cookie banner for privacy laws but you don’t necessarily have to sacrifice speed. Consentmo keeps your store compliant with near-perfect load performance.

Bonus: How To Check If An App is slowing down your store

Even if you want to audit an app yourself and its speed impact on your store, here’s a short step by step how:

1. Run a Before/After Speed Test

This is the most direct method to measure an app’s effect:

Step-by-step:

1. Open WebPageTest.org or GTmetrix.com.
   
2. Enter your store URL and run a test with the app enabled.
   
3. Then, go into your Shopify admin and disable or uninstall the app.
   
4. Run the test again and compare the results.

2. Inspect JavaScript Behavior

Apps that affect speed almost always do so via JavaScript (scripts that run in your customer’s browser).

You can check what’s happening using built-in browser tools:

Step-by-step:

1. Open your store in Google Chrome.
   
2. Right-click anywhere → click Inspect → go to the Network tab.
   
3. Refresh the page and look at the list of files being loaded.

Note: Render-blocking scripts often already show up in red or yellow warnings in PageSpeed Insights.

Pro Tips

• Apps that inject scripts in the <head> tend to hurt performance more than those that defer or load asynchronously.
  
• Even apps that are “disabled” may still inject scripts unless they’re fully uninstalled.
  
• Use tools like Lighthouse for deeper audits. They highlight exactly which scripts are slowing things down.

Conclusion

When it comes to running a Shopify store, we know you’re constantly balancing competing priorities. 

When it comes to app selection, you need reliable solutions which add functionality and stay compliant with privacy laws. But also - keep your UX and store speed in check.

Our testing proved that while these concerns aren’t unfounded, they’re often exaggerated. Well-built apps have a minimal impact on performance. 

In our benchmarks, adding Consentmo increased load time by just 0.3 seconds, while keeping all of Google’s Core Web Vitals in the green. That tiny difference won’t cost you sales or SEO rankings.

And if you are interested in other ways to optimize your Shopify store - we suggest getting your business familiar with the rising Accessibility laws like the European Accessibility Act.